Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 80 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Music Video
Music Video
Criteria Ratings Pts
Creativity/Intentionality
threshold: pts
20 pts
Creative and Intentional
Video demonstrates both creativity and intentionality in its making. This video includes a good idea, and each part of the video demonstrates thought and effort.
16 pts
Intentional
Video accomplishes the assigned task and demonstrates intentionality, but it does not demonstrate creativity and may have needed more time/effort to be its best.
12 pts
There was a thought.
The video accomplishes the basic mission of the project, but there is not evidence of thought or effort beyond that.
0 pts
No effort or intentionality present.
Video does not demonstrate time, intentionality, or effort.
pts
20 pts
--
Composition
threshold: pts
20 pts
Great Composition
Video shots exhibit great use of compositional techniques. Necessary changes are minimal, and the techniques used bring out emotion, purpose, and the best of the video.
16 pts
Moderate Composition
The video exhibits use of compositional techniques, but there may be changes or additional techniques necessary to clean up the composition.
12 pts
Only Basic Composition
The video uses some composition techniques, but they are almost all the same ones and only a simple selection of the most basic principles was chosen.
0 pts
Lack of Composition
The photo does not exhibit proper use of compositional techniques.
pts
20 pts
--
Editing
threshold: pts
20 pts
Seamless and Professional
The editing of this video adds to the overall video quality. This means that the video is not only lacking editing mistakes, but it also includes several well chosen editing techniques which bring out the video's best.
16 pts
Moderate Quality Editing
The editing flows smoothly on a regular basis. There is, however, more than a couple minor mistakes which pull away from the video's quality or are somewhat distracting. Overall, the editing is good but it does not add to the video's quality.
12 pts
Demonstrates Basic Editing
The video demonstrates basic editing, meaning that the video is complete and at least functions, but there may be large pieces of missing content, drastic mistakes, or the editing is distracting from the video.
0 pts
No quality editing present.
Editing lacks proper use of any techniques, and the editing job actually distracts from the video making it difficult to watch,
pts
20 pts
--
Lighting
threshold: pts
20 pts
Full Marks
Lighting is professional, accurate, and artistic. Almost nothing in the lighting is off and the look of the lighting adds a great deal to the video's mood/quality. Additionally, color correction has been applied to the edit with at least a LUT (Look) having been applied with an appropriate, flattering amount of intensity applied.
16 pts
Moderate Lighting Quality
Lighting is done generally well, meaning that it is even, intentional, generally boosts the quality of the video, and has a look that suits the video's story/mood. Though good, the lighting does not yet have an aspect of artistry or precision which makes the video stand out.
12 pts
Demonstrates Basic Lighting
Lighting principles were used, even if not well in all cases. At a minimum, the video is viewable and the lighting is only minorly distracting from the video in terms of its quality.
6 pts
Highly distracting lighting quality.
Either no lighting principles were used, or the lighting present is so distracting or poor that it is distracting from the rest of the video in a way that makes it difficult to watch.
0 pts
No Marks
pts
20 pts
--